stupidness in the news
May. 3rd, 2006 10:52 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
dianec422 articles on the normally-quite-sensible BBC News health page really annoy me today.
First, GPs urged to help obese get slim. Where do you begin with this article?
To paraphrase a comment from a friend's journal, "Which of the methods clinically proven to work in the long term are they going to recommend?" Next, apparently one of the primary tools will be the BMI, which in this day and age seems downright medieval. Two preposterous claims are then made in rapid succession: "This does not mean someone has to change their life." Umm, sorry, yes it does. The changes don't have to be huge or earth-shattering; but if you have an unhealthy lifestyle and you want a healthy one, then you do have to change the things you do every day. I'm terribly sorry, but that's just how life works. Next, "It is not about doctors and ministers telling people what to do." Of course it is, you idiot. Giving someone constructive advice is, in a very real sense, telling them what to do and how to do it. They don't have to listen, of course...
The other headline which blew my mind: America's middle-aged are less fit than the English. But why? Umm... this study was done on people aged 55 to 64; that is NOT middle aged! Or is "middle aged" defined as "median baby boomer age" these days? Eesh.
First, GPs urged to help obese get slim. Where do you begin with this article?
To paraphrase a comment from a friend's journal, "Which of the methods clinically proven to work in the long term are they going to recommend?" Next, apparently one of the primary tools will be the BMI, which in this day and age seems downright medieval. Two preposterous claims are then made in rapid succession: "This does not mean someone has to change their life." Umm, sorry, yes it does. The changes don't have to be huge or earth-shattering; but if you have an unhealthy lifestyle and you want a healthy one, then you do have to change the things you do every day. I'm terribly sorry, but that's just how life works. Next, "It is not about doctors and ministers telling people what to do." Of course it is, you idiot. Giving someone constructive advice is, in a very real sense, telling them what to do and how to do it. They don't have to listen, of course...
The other headline which blew my mind: America's middle-aged are less fit than the English. But why? Umm... this study was done on people aged 55 to 64; that is NOT middle aged! Or is "middle aged" defined as "median baby boomer age" these days? Eesh.
